Donate Today! Help us help others.

Lynch Coaching


Sunday, April 14, 2013

Critical Thinking on LIVING SMART with Patricia Gras

For parents, '42' offers a chance to talk to kids about racism

Harrison Ford, left, as Branch Rickey and Chadwick Boseman (right) as Jackie Robinson in "42." (D. Stevens / MCT)

The Jackie Robinson biopic "42," which opened in theaters nationwide Friday, presents an opportune moment for adults to have meaningful conversations with their kids about the history of racism in the United States.

But with that opportunity comes an array of challenges, especially for younger audiences keen on seeing a story of an iconic sports hero.

It really comes down to language. Given a PG-13 rating for "thematic elements including language" from the Motion Picture Assn. of America, the film doesn't shy away from depicting the racial slurs hurled at Robinson, who was the first African American player in Major League Baseball, starting in 1947 with the Brooklyn Dodgers.

PHOTOS: Scenes from '42'

One scene in particular stands out for its repeated use of the N-word, a phrase some children have yet to be exposed to, while others, especially those who listen to hip-hop, have likely heard.

Robinson, played by Chadwick Boseman, steps up to bat, only to be ridiculed mercilessly by the opposing team's manager, Philidelphia Phillies' Ben Chapman, played by Alan Tudyk. His relentless mockery is fueled by the repetition of the epithet. 

Critics have taken note of the scene, with the L.A. Times' Kenneth Turan writing that the sequence is "especially effective." He continues, "For present-day viewers, especially children, who may not have heard this kind of language in real life, prejudice as naked as this is tough to experience, even on a movie screen."
This is the pivotal issue for parents of younger children interested in seeing the film.  What's age-appropriate, and how much can they handle?

Dr. Alvin F. Poussaint, a professor of psychiatry at Harvard who advocates for responsible media programming but hasn't yet seen "42," says that by age 10, most American children have heard much of the name-calling that goes on between races.

Yet he advises moms and dads to get a second opinion from other parents who have seen the film before taking the kids, even those who are 13. For those parents who are interested in bringing their children to the film, he suggests broadening the discussion beyond black and white to other ethnicities and races.

"Generally by age 10, they understand all that. I think they begin to understand where it fits and they see kids calling each other all kind of names," he said. "And that’s the context that parents should put it in. It’s not just blacks that get called racial slurs, it's Latinos, it's Jews, it's Italians, it’s everybody. And you don’t do that to people."

Poussaint said he is troubled by how the N-word has been used in rap and hip-hop music, its frequent invocation perhaps leaving the impression that it is no longer offensive or hurtful.  Children who listen to such music, he said, may benefit from seeing a movie such as "42," which shows the power of the word and the pain and damage it can inflict.

"The reality of what that word means and how it’s been used to repress and belittle, humiliate and demean black people is important for them to understand," said Poussaint, who is black and specializes in parenting issues related to African American children.

PHOTOS: Game-changing baseball movies

"I would bet there are more black parents who know that their kids use that word who might want to, as an antidote, have them see what a vicious word it is," he said, "and how it was used against someone who could have been their grandfather."

To be sure, much has changed in the more than 65 years since Robinson joined the league; many of today's junior high students may not remember a president before Barack Obama.

Rachel Robinson, Jackie's widow, said part of her motivation in allowing the makers of "42" to tell her husband's story was so today's children could revisit history and recognize the progress that's been made — while acknowledging the challenges that remain.

"I wanted to make this movie so children would feel inspired by Jack," she said in an interview with the L.A. Times. "We've made some remarkable progress and I'm very pleased with what's been done, but racism still exists, and in terms of having equal opportunities, we're not there yet."

Steven Zeitchik contributed to this report.
'42' director: I didn't soft-pedal racially charged language
'42' has Jackie Robinson's number
Jackie Robinson's widow says '42' hits home
'42' will outscore 'Scary Movie 5' in its first box-office at-bat

Watercooler talk is history, now we need an encyclopedia to understand what is our common culture.

Listen To The Original Story

In film and TV, pop culture references are meant to give a knowing nod to those in the audience who understand the joke. But in an increasingly segmented and diverse country, those jokes may be pulling in fewer laughs. This story originally aired on Morning Edition on Jan. 18, 2013.

The Gun Debate and World Wide Media, Goolge and Anonymous

ON THE MEDIA: Gun Anecdotes, What To Know about the Avian Flu, and Grindr.

Since the Sandy Hook shootings, gun violence anecdotes have been the centerpiece of much of the reporting about guns. OTM asks if there's a better way. Also, who to listen to about the new avian flu and everything you need to know about Grindr.

Why We Might be Telling the Wrong Stories in the Gun Debate

As the Senate debates gun control for the first time in decades, we’re awash in stories we might never have heard but for Newtown. Brooke speaks with New York Times op-ed writer Joe Nocera, who's tracking gun violence daily on his blog The Gun Report. And Bob speaks with reporter Sheryl Gay Stolberg about why we're stuck with anecdotes instead of data in the gun discussion.

Lúnasa - Killarney Boys Of Pleasure

Reporting Global Health Epidemics In A Wired World

In China, a new form of avian flu, called H7N9, has killed 10 people and infected an additional 28.  China’s gotten plaudits from the global health community for its transparency and responsiveness to this outbreak. But that's partly because many remember how China lied about SARS in 2002, a decision that killed hundreds. Public health reporter Maryn McKenna talks to Bob about what the standards are for reporting health epidemics in a wired world.

Bonobo - Cirrus

Can A Small Search Engine Take On Google?

Duck Duck Go is a small search engine based in Pennsylvania that is, according to Google at least, a Google competitor. OTM producer Chris Neary talks with Duck Duck Go founder Gabriel Weinberg, SearchEngineLand's Danny Sullivan, and a dedicated Duck Duck Go user about the site. Also, each of the OTM producers try Duck Duck Go, and only Duck Duck Go, for a week.

Theme from I Dream of Jeannie

Meet Grindr: A Gaydar in Every Pocket

Grindr is a phone app that allows gay men to find other users based on their proximity. Brooke speaks with Jaime Woo, author of Meet Grindr: How One App changed the Way We Connect about the app's effect on our understanding of privacy.

Joel Simkhai, Grindr-in-Chief

Brooke talks to Grindr founder Joel Simkhai about what inspired the app and how it manages to make money.

A Casual, Anonymous Interview

OTM producer Doug Anderson fires up Grindr and meets up with another guy for a casual, anonymous...interview.

Fred Astair - I'm Putting All My Eggs In One Basket