Welcome to www.comprofessor.com a.k.a. Lynch Coaching: Media and Communication Prof's News and Views from Art Lynch. This blog exists to stimulate critical thinking, provide information on communication and media, stimulate discussion and share ideas. For additional media and other news see also sagactoronline.com. Thank you and tell your friends. - Art Lynch
Presidential debate coaches from past campaigns
say things used to be much simpler. GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney
is spending three days in Vermont this week preparing for next month's
debates. President Obama has started his debate preparations too.
RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:
It's MORNING EDITION, from NPR News. Good morning. I'm Renee Montagne.
STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:
And I'm Steve Inskeep.
Romney has not done any campaigning the last few days. He's in Vermont
with senior aides, preparing for debates next month. And even as
President Obama prepares for tonight's big speech, campaign aides say he
has been preparing for debates, too. NPR's Ari Shapiro asked past
debate coaches what happens behind the scenes.
ARI SHAPIRO, BYLINE: Things used to be so much simpler, says Michael Waldman. He's a veteran of the Clinton administration.
WALDMAN: John F. Kennedy prepped for the first presidential televised
debate by looking at a few note cards with one aide.
Nowadays, staffers assemble thick briefing books months in advance.
Once the candidate has studied them, he stands on mock debate stage with
a carefully chosen mock opponent and cameras rolling. That's so
everyone can review the footage afterwards. Karen Hughes remembers long
days in Crawford, Texas with George W. Bush and a parade of experts.
HUGHES: So it could be anything from Medicare to, if you had tax
policy, you'd have the economists in the room. If it was foreign policy,
you'd have the foreign policy specialists.
The goal is to exhaust every possible question and rehearse the perfect
answer for each one, so by the time you get to the debate itself, there
are no surprises. But memorizing the book alone is not enough. The
candidates have to learn how to boil answers down and tie them into a
campaign theme that makes sense to voters. Republican Ed Rollins coached
presidential candidate Jack Kemp in 1988.
ROLLINS: You know, Jack had 40 ideas in his head at any one given
moment. And you have to get the answers down to 30 or 60 seconds. It was
kind of hard for him to do.
you've finally got the substance, style is just as critical. Al Gore
learned that lesson the hard way. In the 2000 race, Gore had all the
answers. Problem was, he acted like a guy who had all the answers. This
sigh may have handed debate victory to George W. Bush.
(SOUNDBITE OF PRESIDENTIAL DEBATE)
PRESIDENT GEORGE W. BUSH: I've had a record of appointing judges in the state of Texas.
(SOUNDBITE OF SIGH)
That's what a governor gets to do. A governor...
After the debate, style turned to spin. The Bush team talked about how
domineering Gore was, how he argued with the moderator and invaded
Bush's space. It worked. Bush was judged the debate's winner. But four
years later, Bush had body language problems of his own. Every time John
Kerry answered a question, Bush would frown. Karen Hughes had to break
the news to him after the debate.
thought he did a good job in the debate. And I said, well, except for
that cut shot when you kept scowling at the camera.
The candidates and their coaches know that one good zinger can win a
debate, and they spend days searching for the perfect phrase. Ed Rollins
worked with Ronald Reagan.
ROLLINS: If you hit on a couple of those, you sort of dominate the news media for the next couple of days.
For example, in 1984, people openly wondered whether Reagan was too old
for another four years in office. This line was carefully scripted and
(SOUNDBITE OF PRESIDENTIAL DEBATE)
PRESIDENT RONALD REAGAN: I am not going to exploit, for political purposes, my opponent's youth and inexperience.
One of the best-remembered zingers of all time came from Lloyd Bentsen
in 1988. Debate coach Bob Shrum knew that Bentsen's opponent liked
comparing himself to JFK. And sure enough, Dan Quayle made the
comparison in the debate.
BOB SHRUM: And Lloyd Bentsen was entirely prepared to turn to him and say...
(SOUNDBITE OF VICE PRESIDENTIAL DEBATE)
BENTSEN: Senator, I served with Jack Kennedy. I knew Jack Kennedy. Jack
Kennedy was a friend of mine. Senator, you're no Jack Kennedy.
There's a balancing act, though. While debate coaches hate surprise,
they don't want to over-prepare, either. A candidate with too much
information in his head can seem unfocused. Karen Hughes says George W.
Bush understood that danger as far back as the Texas governor's race.
He told the staff: If you have any ideas for what I should say, tell
Karen. And it was a very smart move, because by debate day, my head was
so crammed with stuff, I could not think.
All of this preparation comes down to one goal, and it isn't convincing
a panel of judges, says former Clinton aide Michael Waldman.
All these candidates know that it's not about winning points in a high
school debating championship. It's about persuading the public one way
or another that you're ready to be president.
It's a strange gauntlet to run, because there are lots of things a
president has to be good at. But outside of a campaign, the president of
the United States will never actually debate anyone.
Ari Shapiro, NPR News.